This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Very poor treatment in Emergency"

About: Wonthaggi Hospital / Emergency Department

(as a relative),

My partner was seen recently after a fall at work. They were sent to Xray in extreme pain. The images showed no breaks and the doctor seemed happy to send my partner home even though their pain was not under control.

The advice we were given was if there's no improvement in a few days, contact our GP. My partner asked if they could do an ultrasound but the doctor said no. We then had to wait until several days to see a GP who referred my partner to radiology for an ultrasound. While attending radiology that day, the radiologist was very concerned and informed my partner that they had suffered a very serious injury and the radiologist felt that it was an urgent repair. The radiologist immediately informed a doctor from emergency who advised my partner to go back to the emergency desk to be seen again.

My partner had suffered 6 days of unmanaged pain by this time and they were beside themselves. After a 3 hour wait, the doctor took us into the triage room and from the moment we arrived, we felt as if we were annoying the doctor. We found them to be short and not in the least reassuring. The doctor spoke to an orthopedic surgeon and sent us on our way to make our appointment with a doctor who was on leave! We believe this doctor would have known this, as they spoke with the surgeon.

The following morning, we went to the pharmacy to get a script filled that the doctor had given us the night before, and were sent away because the script was not filled out correctly. We also asked this doctor if we would need the images from the ultrasound, for the surgeon, and were told that it wasn't necessary.

When we finally got onto the surgeon's rooms, they asked for the images! This meant another half-hour wait in radiology because, in my opinion, the doctor was more concerned with getting us out of the hospital, than making calm, well-informed decisions.

My partner suffered for nearly a week because of, what we believe to be, a lack of professionalism from the ED staff. We are meant to be able to look to the Doctors for reassurance and a calm manner. Instead, we felt like we were in the way.

I love our hospital and our family has relied on it many times. The nurses and staff on the wards are beautiful and their care is wonderful. But in our experience, the ED let us down. It has been really distressing to see my partner in so much pain that seems as though it could have been avoided if the first doctor had just done the ultrasound when my partner was first taken in. In my opinion, it is easy for mistakes to be made, but when people have pain and serious injuries, it is so imperative that your ED staff have the patients' best interest at heart, not what seems to be the ED turnover times!

Tags added by staff members:
Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Jan Child, CEO, Bass Coast Health 2 years ago
Jan Child
CEO,
Bass Coast Health
Submitted on 12/07/2021 at 4:15 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 4:17 PM


picture of Jan Child

Hello and huge thanks to you for taking the time to provide your feedback. Thank you also for speaking subsequently with our Director of Emergency Dan – it is always very helpful to be able to talk directly to you and understand the issues.

I know that Dan has apologised on behalf of our service – I hope you have been reassured by Dan that whilst our ED staff are always under enormous pressure to treat patients quickly, this is not driven by our wish to meet KPIs but driven by the reality that our ED is small and sub-optimal and we don’t have enough treatment space. Dan might also have mentioned that the ED has been particularly busier of late than usual, with more patients presenting in our already small space (bring on our new ED next year!). Please accept my apologies also – even with these constraints, it is always hugely important that our patients feel heard, and supported. I know that Dan is discussing your concerns with those involved in your care and he will get back to you directly.

The issue of ED ordering outpatient tests, rather than sending you to your GP is complex, and Dan is going to review our processes here – we know that most EDs refer to GPs for follow-up tests because of the nature of our intervention being one-off – but this will clearly be problematic if access to GPs is compromised (and we know this can be an issue). Dan will discuss this with his colleagues to see if we can work out a process to facilitate our ability to order from ED, but not assume ongoing care.

I also understand Dan is following up with our contracted Radiology provider as to why the ultrasonographer thought you had an urgent condition when none of the medical staff felt had the same level of urgency. This sort of information from the treating team can create unnecessary worry for patients and should be avoided.

I note your concern that you were sitting in an assessment room and could hear other patients being triaged and that this made you uncomfortable. We will once again remind staff of their requirement to be vigilant about the proper use of assessment space (particularly in our tricky environments – thank goodness we are building a new ED and a new Community hospital).

The manner of the doctor who reviewed you the second time is concerning to us– it is our expectation that our staff are NOT dismissive but are caring. Dan will follow up with the doctor directly and provide support and feedback to make sure that our expectations, and yours, are understood.

I note that you were concerned about having to make your own appointment with the surgeon, only to find out that they were on holiday. I know you will understand that for us to make every follow-up appointment would delay the urgent and emergency treatment that we need to provide, hence why non-urgent referrals are left with the patient. I understand that you have now seen the surgeon who previously repaired your shoulder, and he has advised a ‘wait and see’ approach with an MRI. At least one silver lining is that you can have your MRI locally now that we have commenced an MRI service.

I thank you sincerely for reaching out to us. There are always opportunities for improvement and you have helped us understand ours. Dan will be in touch to let you know how things progress from here. I wish you a speedy recovery.

Kind Regards,

Jan

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k