Text size

Theme

Language

"Over servicing and affecting health"

About: Fiona Stanley Hospital

(as the patient),

I had surgery 5 months ago. I am being constantly sent outpatient appointments for various departments and places that I believe are unnecessary. It is as often as every second week they are telling me I must travel to them from the country for appointments. They continually say that the appointments must be face to face. 

Today was another of the, in my opinion, unnecessary demands from them and their apparent refusal to accept that I am not just next door and cannot get there whenever they want.  I advised them I could not attend because I already had other appointments (for treatments), and also was unable to get transport to get there.

It is not always possible to get support workers to take you on NDIS which they have been told of and claim to understand. It was cancelled by phone and also online. They rang later to say that I should have gone anyway because they did not accept the cancellation. They tried to tell me I would have to go in person for an appointment in the next couple of weeks, but seemingly refuse to say why they will not do it by telehealth. The call was from a registrar that said every appointment must be in person. But could not say why. They also said that they cannot do appointments on one day because the appointment time is not actually an appointment, but just a cattle call when everyone is told to be there.

I am disabled, live in the country, and have no transport of my own to get there. It was suggested that I use taxis which are at a cost of around $285 each way. I know that because they kicked me out after surgery having said transports home was arranged, and they took ,etp the front door and told storing a taxi. I then found I had to pay it myself from my pension.

I believe that these appointments are not anything that cannot be done by telehealth as it is just the doctors (usually just a registrar I believe), apparently having an open house so all comers can have a look at you, and seemingly socialising with other staff while you are in the room with them.

They also have told me that they have planned to do cosmetic procedures that I do not want and have told them so, but they keep saying I have to go and sign the papers and set a date. Refusing appointments is not accepted.

They also refer to totally irrelevant places.  They refused to accept that the cost of their demands is too much in terms of money, time, and also on my health. I should not be having to get treatment for conditions caused by their, in my opinion, unreasonable demands. 

I keep getting told that I should go to their appointments that, I believe, do nothing rather than appointments where I am getting treatment for pre existing conditions. I recall I was told that going to see them was more important than attending physiotherapy and specialists actually treating conditions. 

Part of the treatments I am needing are from the effects of what they did, but never warned me about. I was told that they knew that the problems I now have would happen, but they cannot remember to tell everyone everything.

Between them, people they are expecting me to go to, and other medical appointments (which are actually necessary for treatment, those not for treatment being done by telehealth even local ones) I ended up with 20 appointments in 35 days. Definitely over servicing in my opinion. They claim that it is a team of different departments is the reason I am being constantly told to go there. Except, I think that if they really were a team they should be able to organise appointments all in one or at the very least share their information with each other, as they are all looking at one small area and should have access to the same notes.

I think that a hospital should be able to understand that their over servicing and unrealistic expectations, in my opinion, cause worse health outcomes. I now know why I am hearing of so many people rejecting medical care. I am on the verge of doing that too due to this hospital.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Luke Dix, Acting Executive Director, Fiona Stanley Fremantle Hospital Group, South Metropolitan Health Service 2 weeks ago
Luke Dix
Acting Executive Director, Fiona Stanley Fremantle Hospital Group,
South Metropolitan Health Service
Submitted on 18/03/2026 at 1:24 PM
Published on Care Opinion Australia at 2:20 PM


picture of Luke Dix

Dear not a happy patient,

Thank you for sharing your experience with Fiona Stanley Hospital (FSH).

I am sorry to read about the ongoing frustration you have described in relation to frequency and uncoordinated scheduling of your outpatient appointments.

I recognise that repeated face‑to‑face appointments can be particularly challenging for patients who live in regional areas, have a disability, or rely on transport and support services. While some appointments do require in‑person review for clinical reasons, this is not always the case, and we acknowledge the importance of considering individual circumstances wherever possible.

Support options may be available for eligible patients who need to travel long distances for specialist care, including assistance coordinated through the Patient Assisted Travel Scheme (PATS) in conjunction with the treating specialist. This can be raised with your treating specialist by phone, email, or during an appointment.

As this platform is anonymous, it is difficult for me to provide a more informed response without knowing details such as the specialties involved and of course your personal details. In order to allow a more comprehensive response to your feedback I encourage you to contact our Patient and Family Liaison Service (PFLS) on (08) 6152 4013 during business hours, or via email at FSHFeedback@health.wa.gov.au. This will allow us to review your concerns in detail and liaise with the relevant teams to seek clarity regarding appointment frequency, coordination, use of telehealth, and transport considerations.

Thank you for providing your feedback and I hope we are able to assist you further.

Kind regards,

Luke Dix

A/Executive Director

Fiona Stanley Fremantle Hospitals Group

South Metropolitan Health Service

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by not a happy patient (the patient)

I believe you have followed the script you always use. I have been to the patient liaison service and they said that appointments would be coordinated or done by telehealth. Except the outpatient departments refuse to do it.

As for PATS, I think that is of no use if you do not have transport! All I believe they do is when you send in a form (provided the department seen has agreed to sign it) is give you a token amount after the fact to go towards the fuel cost. If you do not have transport to get there, in my opinion, it does nothing! Please educated yourself on what a place does before telling people to go there. I understand that PATS does not, and never has, provided transport.

I have been told by your staff that it is policy that appointments have to be be in person, despite it being in writing that telehealth is available. I feel there is not a reason to demand that people must go there. A photo can be done by the local hospital and sent in conjunction with telehealth, which is all that has been happening at these, in my opinion, useless appointments.

And I believe you fail to address, how you can say it is necessary to keep coming for individual appointments for each person to look at the same things and take the same photos. In my opinion, a team works together, not has every person in it doing the same things as every other just at a different time. I think they should be trained that if they want to just see that a wound from surgery is still healed after 5 months that every department does not have to have you come so they can say "it is still healed. We did a good job". I believe they can see that on telehealth or from the photo that one of the many different departments that I am told I must attend gets. Can you not all share that info?

Also I have been told that an appointment cannot be cancelled due to having other conflicting appointments and lack of transport unless the doctor accepts the cancellation. If I have appointments I actually need, including treatment for other conditions, or cannot get transport, I am not going to pander to them. It is called consent.

Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k