Text size

Theme

Language

"A horrible experience"

About: Bairnsdale Hospital / Emergency Department

(as a partner),

My partner's knee popped out and they couldn’t get it back in, my partner was in excruciating pain so we called an ambulance, only to be told that an ambulance wasn't coming. My in law and I carefully loaded my partner up in the car and took them to the Bairnsdale Hospital Emergency Department.

Once in the waiting room it took hours for my partner to be checked and given any sort of pain medication. Meanwhile my partner is nearly passing out from the pain. They got told they would Xray my partner's knee but after a few more hours was told that the Xray department was closed and they would attempt to put their knee in a splint so my partner could go home as they didn’t have enough beds. Not once had my partner been properly examined and no extra pain relief was offered before attempting putting the splint on.

My partner was inconsolable and shaking in pain to the point the person next to my partner had to press the call button as no one was seemingly paying attention, my partner had to take the splint off themselves to relieve the pain. The Intern said that the X-ray is most likely not needed but maybe an MRI or ultrasound, I felt they had absolutely no idea what they were doing and had hardly checked my partners knee. My partner said they had never felt so neglected by a service, a service that is meant to have a duty of care.

My partner was told there was nothing they could do until the following day and discharged them with no pain medication and no follow up support at 11.30pm. Absolutely disgusting, in my opinion.

My partner couldn’t weight bare on their leg so they put them in a wheelchair and pushed my partner out the front to wait for me to collect them. A doctor gave my partner a script for oxy with no way to collect until the next day. I felt this was pathetic.  

I walked in a demanded they either keep my partner over night or transport them to another hospital. How did they expect my partner to go throughout the night with no pain medication? I told them I would only call an ambulance again and be right back. We got told there was nothing else they could do.

The doctor eventually agreed to give my partner 2x oxy tabs and supplied us with an Xray form for the next day. The following morning my partner woke up with a purple foot and was still unable to walk or weight bare, back up to the ED to finally get an Xray and then to be told we had to go to the GPs clinic to get a referral for an MRI, which could have been done the day before. We headed to Advantage HealthPoint in town where, luckily they have an emergency walk in clinic available.

Half an hour there was a thousand times better then going to the BRHS ED, my partner was throughly checked, anti inflammatory tablets and pain meds were supplied and the referral was sent. Based on this experience, we won’t be going to BRHS for any emergency health care, we will be attending the medical centre where I feel the right care will be given. 

We have heard multiple horror stories about the Bairnsdale Emergency Department but to experience it I felt was horrific. 

You have a duty of care and we are disgusted at how my partner was treated. I feel my partner was neglected and thrown out the door like they were a waste of their time. We are well aware they are busy and short staffed but I believe it’s no excuse to put someone’s life in danger. We are still without any answers and who knows what permanent damage my partner will have. 

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Bairnsdale Regional Health Service 3 days ago
Submitted on 7/08/2026 at 4:48 PM
Published on Care Opinion Australia at 5:07 PM


Thank you for sharing your experience. I am very sorry to hear what your partner, and you, went through.

From what you have described, this was a frightening and upsetting experience. Seeing someone you care about in pain, feeling they are not getting the help they need, and leaving the hospital still worried about their condition would be distressing for anyone. I understand why you felt frustrated and why this experience has stayed with you.

I would like to explain a little about how Emergency Departments work. Patients are not always seen in the order they arrive. Instead, we use a triage system that helps us identify who needs urgent care first. This means that people with life-threatening conditions, such as a heart attack, stroke, serious injury or breathing problems, will be treated before others, regardless of when they arrived.

I understand that this can be difficult to accept when someone is in pain and waiting for care. Pain can be exhausting, and it is hard to watch someone you care about suffer.

Managing pain in the Emergency Department can sometimes be complex. The type of treatment we provide depends on a person's symptoms, medical history and the cause of their illness or injury. However, every patient should feel that their pain is taken seriously, that they are being checked on regularly, and that they understand what is happening and why.

What stands out most in your feedback is not just the waiting time, but that you and your partner felt unsupported and unheard. Good healthcare is about more than medical treatment. It is also about kindness, communication and making people feel cared for. I am sorry that this was not your experience.

Thank you for taking the time to share your story. Feedback like yours helps us understand what we are doing well and where we need to improve. Hearing directly from patients and families is an important part of helping us provide better care for our community.

If you feel comfortable doing so, I encourage you to contact our Consumer Feedback team on (03) 5150 3241 or by email at feedback@brhs.com.au so we can learn more about your experience and discuss your concerns further.

Thank you again for sharing your experience. I hope your partner is recovering well, and I wish them a full and speedy recovery.

Hayley
Deputy Director, Patient Access and Flow
Bairnsdale Regional Health Service

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by Another disappionted client of BRHS (a partner)

Thank you for your response Hayley

We are aware how the triage system works in the ED, I used to work for LRH for nearly 10 years. It’s not the wait time that’s most concerning, it’s the lack of support whilst waiting and then the complete lack of healthcare and communication when my partner did get seen.

After getting an MRI recently and fantastic help by advantage HealthPoint team my partner is now heading to Melbourne for surgery as my partner has a severe bucket handle meniscus tear. Something that could have been dealt with earlier.

Thank you for that information, I will be contacting them with our concerns.

Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k