Text size

Theme

Language

"My birth"

About: Busselton Health Campus / Maternity Unit, Childbirth & Parenting Education

(as the patient),

I met with the head of obstetrics late in pregnancy, and had a non-standard management plan signed, stating I could have a waterbirth despite the recommendations. I was aware of the risks and benefits and consented to this. I was so thrilled Lauren was open to and willing to make this option available to me in Busselton. I had had 2 previous uncomplicated vaginal births and one caesarean for breech.

I came into hospital after labouring at home and progressing quite quickly as it was my fourth birth. When I arrived I was ready to push and my husband started running the bath as this was the plan. The midwife seemed quite stressed and started asking irrelevant questions instead of adapting to and reading the situation at hand. They also started telling me all the risks of being in the water, while I was in the middle of pushing, which I had already consented to. The midwife asked me to hop out of the bath several times which I declined as was the previous arrangement. I felt that they weren't able to move past the fact that I was declining standard care and provide me with care to the best of their ability in the situation.

My relative was coming up to help but they were kept in the waiting room so that my husband had to go fetch them. When he was gone the babies head was born. The midwife was not next to me when I birthed the head and was very distracted up to this point. At which point the midwife demanded I get out of the bath and pushed the emergency button. As far as I was aware, nothing was wrong. I was a women giving birth and there was no need for the alarm. My husband and relative returned just in time for the birth of our baby. Baby was born in good condition, breathing and pink, but didn’t cry straight away, calm from the water birth. The midwife was quite stressed by the baby not crying. Myself and baby completely fine. I remained in the bath until I was ready to birth the placenta, which came away with no issues. Once baby was born the midwife was much more at ease.

Given that I had pre-signed a non-standard management plan I feel that my name and details should have been on the running sheet. As far as I was aware, management knew about me but it did feel like it may not have been passed all the way day to the staff on the ground. Having the non-standard plan in place was such a relief for me leading up to birth, and I would love this option to be available for women in the future. But this needs to be something that is clearly documented, as well as handed down to the midwives working on the floor, so that they are aware of any non-standard plans coming up.

I feel that the midwife was not confident and overwhelmed by a busy night in the maternity unit and put out by me refusing standard care. They also seemed stuck on asking irrelevant details for an impending birth, and should have easily been able to get the pertinent information from a quick read through my file. I also feel that they were not fully confident in water births which influenced my level of care. Had I not been a confident multip, this would have thrown my resolve in labour and affected the way I birthed. I feel that all midwives should be trained in water births and how to facilitate things such taking a fetal heart rate in the water, etc.

Overall, I was so thankful for the plan that Lauren was willing to sign for me, and I hope more women can have this option in the future. But I would encourage better communication to staff, and more basic training around waterbirth to increase confidence and preparedness. Birth in water is not an emergency, it is a normal event.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Marnie Bilsby, Clinical Nurse Manager, Maternity, Busselton Health Campus yesterday
We are preparing to make a change
Marnie Bilsby
Clinical Nurse Manager, Maternity,
Busselton Health Campus
Submitted on 8/09/2026 at 3:49 PM
Published on Care Opinion Australia at 3:57 PM


Dear librawy39,

Thank you for taking the time to share your birth experience and congratulations on the arrival of your baby.

We are pleased to hear that you felt supported during your pregnancy discussions with Dr Lauren and that a non-standard management plan was developed that reflected your wishes after careful consideration of the risks, benefits, and your individual circumstances. Supporting informed choice and shared decision-making is an important part of the care we provide.

I am sorry to hear that aspects of your labour and birth experience did not meet your expectations. It is clear from your feedback that, despite having a documented non-standard management plan in place, you felt this information was not effectively communicated to all staff involved in your care. We acknowledge how frustrating and distressing this must have been during such an important time.

Your feedback has prompted us to review how information regarding women who have attended consultant clinics and have approved non-standard management plans is communicated to clinical staff. As a result, improvements have been made to ensure these plans are more clearly identified and communicated between teams, enabling midwives and medical staff to be aware of agreed management plans when women present in labour. Our aim is to improve continuity of care and ensure staff are better prepared to support women in accordance with their documented birth preferences and care plans.

We also appreciate your comments regarding staff confidence in supporting water births. Feedback such as yours helps us identify opportunities for ongoing education, training, and service improvement to ensure our staff feel equipped and confident to provide safe and supportive care.

Thank you again for sharing your experience. We value both your positive comments regarding the support you received in developing your birth plan and your constructive suggestions for improvement. Consumer feedback plays an important role in helping us improve the care we provide to women and their families.

We wish you and your family all the very best.

Kind regards,

Marnie Bilsby
Clinical Nurse Manager, Maternity Unit
Busselton Health Campus

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k