This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Lack of privacy in ED"

About: St John of God Midland Hospital / Emergency Department

(as the patient),

I recently went to St John of God Midland Emergency Department (ED) with severe lower abdominal pain for what turned our to be a burst ovarian cyst. I appreciate that it was a very busy time (there were 19 people ahead of me as I waited to be triaged, plus many already triaged who were waiting for treatment) however I was really disappointed with the lack of privacy, and general disregard for treating patients confidentially. 

In the several hours I spent in the waiting room, particularly while waiting in the triage seating area, I heard the story of every person who was seen before me. I heard their private details, such as their address. I heard their reasons for presenting at the ED. I heard what medications they were taking, what their symptoms were.  

The triage area has no privacy whatsoever, and because of the partition to separate the nurses from the patients, both parties need to speak loudly to be heard. This may not bother some people, but after hearing everyone else's story I realised that the whole room could probably hear my responses as I was asked about my period, my bowel movements, urination, and other bodily functions and information you generally don't want a room full of strangers to hear. 

The nurse I dealt with at triage did not inspire confidence for me. I had a referral from a GP, who I had seen prior to presenting at ED. I believe the nurse must have only skim-read it, exclaiming, Why are you taking X medication - which was met with confusion until I realised they had read it from the allergies section on the doctor's letter. The nurse several times repeated incorrect information back to me i.e. I would say the pain is mostly in my lower abdomen but is now radiating from my lower back into my legs and they would respond, OK so it's only in your lower back, nowhere else?

There was a staff member in the waiting room going around taking blood pressure and heart rates to provide to the triage nurse, but this was not done in order and I watched people who came in after me get tended to before me. This staff member only reached me as I was being called to the triage desk, 2 hours later. They asked me to take a urine sample so that when I went through for treatment they would have the results, however, this again resulted in an uncomfortable situation as I returned from the bathroom with my uncovered cup and was told to take a seat. There's nothing quite like sitting in a full room of people with an open cup of urine. This was eventually collected from me, but when I was moved through into a bed for treatment, it remained in a sealed bag attached to my folder as the nurse came and went several times, so the perceived rush and need to sit with an open cup of urine in a packed waiting room seemed unnecessary.

After eventually being seen, I was told there was no ultrasound service available as it was now late in the evening. This was the main reason the GP had told me to come to hospital, to clarify the suspected cause of pain/rule out any other possibilities.  I was told that I would get a call in the morning to come back and have the ultrasound, however when I got the call they couldn't fit me in and I had to go to an external site. By the time I had the ultrasound, it was about 17 hours after presenting at ED. Once the ultrasound was performed, no one was able to tell me how I would be able to find out the results and the staff I dealt with seemed confused about the process. It looked like the results would be sent back to the ED but they couldn't tell me how I could get those results. Luckily I had the thought to ask that a copy be sent to my GP as well because I didn't hear anything from the hospital and otherwise I believe I would never have been given the results. 

Overall it seemed like a really ramshackle experience, especially compared to the couple of times I have been to other EDs and the lack of privacy was really disconcerting.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Janet Jones, Director of Nursing, Midwifery and Clinical Governance, St John of God - Midland 4 years ago
Janet Jones
Director of Nursing, Midwifery and Clinical Governance,
St John of God - Midland
Submitted on 29/11/2019 at 1:00 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 1:02 PM


Dear endowarrior123,

Thank you for outlining your concerns regarding your recent visit to the Emergency Department (ED) at St John of God Midland Public Hospital (SJGMPH).

l am disappointed you did not receive the standard of care you expected during your presentation and apologise for your experience. You have raised some very important issues regarding the lack of privacy in the triage area. SJGMPH regards the privacy of patients as a very high priority and while every effort is made to protect our patients' privacy, there are challenges in managing this issue in the triage area and we acknowledge we need to do better.

The hospital has established a Triage Working Party to address issues that affect a patient’s journey through the ED and your correspondence will be shared with this group.

I apologise for the lack of communication around the scheduling of your ultrasound and the inconvenience caused. Your feedback has been taken seriously and I would appreciate the opportunity to speak with you about your experience and look into the matters raised in more depth. To allow me to do this, I will need further information and would appreciate it if you would contact our Patient Experience Team on 9462 4901.

I hope you are feeling better and we look forward to hearing from you.

Thanks and kind regards

Janet Jones

Director of Nursing,Midwifery and Clinical Governance

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k