This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Lack of empathy and understanding"

About: Geraldton Hospital

(as a parent/guardian),

It has taken me a while to write this as I was unsure what I wanted to say.

A few months ago, I attended an appointment with my adult child at the mental health unit in Geraldton. They had been so ill for many weeks and I felt it important to give them more support, to show how much we cared.

My child was seen by a psychiatrist and a nurse at the mental unit. Prior to the appointment they had been unable to leave their flat for weeks through anxiety and depression. My child was unable to get out of bed for days on end. I shop for them, answer their letters, make appointments for doctors, attend all appointments with them and anything else which may be needed during this time. My child did not answer their door and would not answer their phone if the number was unknown to them.

During the appointment at the mental unit, I was shocked to see how my child was treated by the psychiatrist. I felt there was no empathy and they continually told my child that they felt that my child had been misdiagnosed with bipolar. They believe my child has a personality disorder and not bipolar. My child was diagnosed many years ago with bipolar by a private psychiatrist. This has been confirmed by numerous other psychiatrists including a psychiatrist in another country.

I was shocked at the way my child was treated as I believe all my child was asking for was help to somehow alleviate their anxieties. The psychiatrist kept asking my child what help do they wanted. My child would reply that they did not know what help they needed just that they wanted to start doing normal things again. I believe the psychiatrist must have repeated the same question more than 6 times when the nurse interjected and said that perhaps Neami National (next to Joondalup Mental Hospital) might be the place where my child could get help to start coping with normal everyday occurrences. There was no response from the psychiatrist about Neami National, so I asked the nurse for the details as I thought this could be helpful for my child. This nurse went and looked up Neami National for my child and we took immediate action. A referral from my child’s doctor lead them to have a placement at Neami for almost 30 days and they are at present in the support unit now.

I thank the nurse for their help as if it was not for their interjecting at the time my child perhaps would not be getting the help they so needed. I felt not once did the psychiatrist help even when Neami was mentioned, it was the nurse who explained it to us.

I feel it is important to let you know that my child really needs help and I believe they are at a loss at times to find that help. I felt that the psychiatrist was aggressive and lacked empathy and understanding. They gave me a feeling it was my child’s fault they had a mental illness.

Since entering Neami I believe my child has found that after the appointment with the psychiatrist in Geraldton they were taken off their books at the mental health unit, although it was through the nurse’s care they are now getting the treatment at Neami. My child has now been given another referral to the mental health unit in Geraldton from Neami National.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Michele Young, REOC Lead, Executive Services, WACHS-Midwest 4 years ago
Michele Young
REOC Lead, Executive Services,
WACHS-Midwest
Submitted on 19/02/2020 at 11:00 AM
Published on Care Opinion at 11:05 AM


picture of Michele Young

Dear zulusz34,

Thank you for taking the time to share you and your child's experience on Patient Opinion. I was disappointed to read your story and I am so very sorry that you and your child have experienced our service in this way. As a mother myself I know how stressful it can be when your child is unwell and how vulnerable they can be. Your experience does not meet our commitment to providing high-quality person-centred, compassionate care. Please be assured that we take your feedback very seriously and your story has been passed on to our Executive team for review.

Communication is key to a positive health care experience and is about making a connection between a person who is unwell and vulnerable, and another person who is there to help, which is the start of a relationship that can instantly build trust in difficult circumstances. This is the first step towards providing truly person-centred, compassionate care and is essential to ensure safe continuous care. It appears based on your experience that we need to do some further work in this area.

Your feedback has also provided an opportunity for us to reflect on the importance of empathy, kindness and compassion and the importance of treating our health service users as individuals by understanding their unique needs. It is so important for us to see our health service users as a person first before an illness or the reason they are using our service. I was so pleased to read that the information and advice you received from the nurse resulted in a positive outcome for your child and they were able to get the help they needed.

We don’t always get it right, learning from experiences like you and your child's is an important part of continuous improvement for our service and we would really like the opportunity to speak with you to investigate this matter to see what we can do better and where we can improve. We would be grateful if you could contact Jamie Robson, Regional Manager Midwest Mental Health Service on 0419 546 285 or Jamie.Robson@health.wa.gov.au or myself on 9956 8695 or Michele.Young@health.wa.gov.au.

Thank you again for sharing you and your child's experience with us, it has given us an opportunity to reflect and improve our service going forward. I wish you and your family the very best and I do hope to hear from you very soon.

Kind regards

Michele

Coordinator Executive Services

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k