This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"ED experience"

About: Broome Health Campus / Emergency Department

(as a service user),

I recently attended Broome Hospital with my young child who was experiencing difficulty breathing along with other respiratory symptoms. We arrived late at night and were triaged quickly through the isolation zone in ED. My child was subsequently diagnosed with a chest infection and given the appropriate medication and we were sent home. I left hospital feeling positive with the interaction I had with all staff involved - the nurses and Dr assigned to us were kind, compassionate and thorough in their assessment and treatment. The staff asked us to represent in the morning to just give my child another once over to make sure they had improved as we were due to travel.

I am disappointed to say that the second interaction the next morning could not have been more opposite. When I presented to ED in the morning, I explained that we had been in the night before, had been diagnosed and begun treatment for a chest infection, and then asked to come back before we travelled. When we were called through, the clinician who greeted us was completely gowned up (fine, I understand that is a requirement given the times we live in) and holding a swab in their hand. They asked why we had presented and I repeated the details I had given the triage nurse, which at the time made me question whether they had actually read the notes left in my child’s chart?

The clinician immediately asked me to consent to giving my child a swab. I declined and I felt their tone completely changed. I was spoken to in a manner that to me felt demeaning, condescending and aggressive. The clinician asked me to explain why I would decline and when I said that I thought it was unnecessary because we already had a diagnosis of chest infection and I felt it would be traumatic to my child, they subjected me to a lecture that I felt bordered on intimidation and coercion. I think they had already decided my child would be swabbed before they had even bothered to find out the details of my child's case given they were holding the swab in their hand before we had even entered the room.

The clinician made me feel belittled and I felt as though they were not respecting my right to consent to medical treatment on behalf of my child. I am not against having the swabs done, but I think it was not logical in our circumstance to give one and that it was just being done for statistical purposes. 

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from David Woodward, Acting Senior Medical Officer, Broome Hospital, WA Country Health Service 3 years ago
David Woodward
Acting Senior Medical Officer, Broome Hospital,
WA Country Health Service

Doctor at Broome Hospital

Submitted on 20/04/2021 at 12:24 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 1:00 PM


Hi Appleworm99,

Thanks for getting in touch to tell us about your experience in ED. I was pleased to hear that your first interaction with the ED went well and I hope your child is well on the way to recovery by now.

My name is Dr David Woodward and I am the Senior Medical Officer at Broome Hospital and I would really like to talk with you about the second interaction you had in the emergency department. I am almost certain that I was involved in your child's case at one point but I want to be sure so I would really appreciate you getting in touch with me by mobile phone: 0419 196 947 or via email: david.woodward@health.wa.gov.au.

I can only apologise for your experience in the ED and reassure you that I have spoken to clinicians to reflect on how their approaches could be done differently to prevent your experience from being repeated for someone else in the future.

Regards

Dave Woodward

Senior Medical Officer

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k