This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Withholding treatment"

About: Albany Health Campus / Emergency Department Albany Health Campus / Mental Health Unit

(as a service user),

Every year I go into the Albany hospital mental health unit to see if someone has developed what I feel is a grain of compassion or humanity and changed what I believe to be the arbitrary and disgusting policy of withholding treatment for those suffering ADD and ADHD.

In my opinion, it's akin to saying don't treat anyone presenting at emergency with life-threatening trauma to the left arm, only treat life-threatening trauma to the right arm, in what I feel is its stupidity.

I had, however, come to terms with the mental health unit being what I believe to be intentionally neglectful of its basic duty of care, but last year I was clipped by a car at work and it caused what I call a ricochet.

It's an unexpected event or person that changes my mental ecosystem so drastically the usual routine, support network and self-monitoring can't cope.

Not only have my visits to the mental health unit at the Albany hospital been, in my opinion, completely void of compassion, or even the most basic of treatments, they leave me in a worse state of mental health than before I reluctantly sought their aid.

But it is the last visit recently that is the subject of this story.

After going through the apparent obligatory, we don't prescribe medication that can actually help "why?" Just because of rhetoric, a doctor prescribes me something that is apparently exactly the same as the diazepam but without the pesky potential for the possibility of maybe addiction.

Great, I say, and leave feeling hopeful that I can be myself again for the first time in two years.

They had absolutely no effect, so I asked the pharmacist and was told they are, as I understand it, nothing at all like the benzodiazepines (that I believe work) and take 30 days to build enough levels to be effective, and here's the kicker, apparently most likely prescribed to try and elicit the placebo effect!

I literally felt the last straw snap and plunged into complete helplessness and rage.

I went to emergency with the hope of getting answers, but was in such a state I think I was basically incoherent.

They offered me medication which I declined a number of times before accepting it would enable me to communicate and I suppose stop being so hostile.

Within 10 minutes of taking the medication I had calmed down enough to tell them why I was there, and within 20 minutes I was myself again.

My lesson for the day was, yes they seemingly do have things that can help and, in my opinion, choose not to help unless it makes life easier for them.

I sarcastically said, "sorry you have to put up with me for an hour, but I live with that person in my head every second of every single day". Childish I know, but I feel this apparent suspended duty of care or even concern is, I believe, killing me and the people who are supposed to help are, in my opinion, on some righteous high horse.

I just can't fathom how seemingly 12% of stimulants prescribed going to people who are using them recreationally is, as I understand it, justification for withholding treatment from the 88% of people who I believe desperately need this medication to lead a healthy life.

How can what I think is such a counterintuitive and detrimental policy exist in a modern health care system?

Why has it not, as I understand it, been reviewed in over ten years?

And who is responsible and accountable for withholding treatment from me?

And is it Albany Health Campus policy to prescribe placebos to those who I believe are a clear danger to themselves and others?

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Matt Wells, Regional Mental Health Manager, Mental Health Services, WACHS Great Southern 2 years ago
Matt Wells
Regional Mental Health Manager, Mental Health Services,
WACHS Great Southern

Manages Great Southern mental health services.

Submitted on 20/10/2021 at 11:18 AM
Published on Care Opinion at 11:21 AM


Dear The Forgotten,

Thank you for reaching out via Care Opinion and taking the time to share your experience with me about your recent attendance at the mental health unit at Albany hospital. I’m sorry to read that you felt that the care provided to you lacked compassion and humanity. This is not how we would like any of our patients or families to feel as we do our best to provide care that is kind and person-centred. I’m very disappointed that this hasn’t been your experience.

In my role as Regional Mental Health Manager, I have liaised with our Consultant Psychiatry team to respond to your questions regarding the prescription of stimulant medications for adults at Great Southern Mental Health Services and the provision of what you feel was a placebo treatment.

I would like you to know that stimulant prescribing in Western Australia is regulated by the Schedule 8 Medicines Prescribing Code (the Code) and the WA Stimulant Regulatory Scheme. This means that both the clinic and individual specialists need to apply for, and be approved for authorisation to prescribe stimulants. There are also specific conditions and regulations which may preclude individuals from being prescribed stimulants. You can find out more information about this on the WA Health website at https://ww2.health.wa.gov.au/Articles/S_T/Stimulant-medicines.

Specialised assessment for Adult ADHD is not a service that is offered at the Great Southern Mental Health Clinic due to the specialty skills required for assessment and regulations around prescribing. This is in line with other Community Mental Health Clinics in Western Australia, rather than a regional difference. However, I can reassure you that when approached regarding adult ADHD assessments and stimulant prescribing, the Great Southern Mental Health Service can screen for other physical or mental health conditions and provide treatment for these as required. We can also provide you with a list of specialists who can assess for and treat Adult ADHD and can provide advice on non-pharmacological management of ADHD.

I can say with complete confidence that the service does not provide placebo medication. All medication is prescribed for a purpose and it is very correct that the majority of medications prescribed in the mental health setting take time, often several weeks, to maximal effect due to the mechanism of action. It is also correct to say that dependence-forming medications are avoided as each practitioner makes an assessment of the risks and benefits of each medication before suggesting it to a patient.

I’m sorry if the reasoning behind the medication you were prescribed wasn’t explained well at the time and I hope my response provides you with some clarification. If you would like to speak to someone directly who can explain this further, I will welcome your call and the opportunity to work with you to understand how we can best support you going forward so that you feel welcomed and supported should you attend the Great Southern Mental Health Clinic in future. My name is Matt Wells and I am the Regional Manager of Mental Health. I can be contacted on 9892 2454.

Thank you again for sharing your experience and allowing us the opportunity to clarify some of your questions around your care and the medications prescribed.

Matt Wells

Regional Manager Mental Health Services

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k