This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"My experience in the emergency department"

About: Bunbury Hospital / Emergency Department

(as the patient),

I recently presented to the ED after days of worsening lower back pain. I have previously had spinal surgeries and had hurt my back again at the beach. I was losing feeling in my leg and bladder and knew this was becoming an issue that needed addressing asap. I had been to the GP and chiro who recommended ED.

In the ED I was in 9/10 pain and feeling nauseas. We had been told to wear masks however I had a sick bag and was sipping water so was not wearing it at all times. When the clinician called me in for assessment, I recall they asked me loudly, and I felt rudely, in front of the entire ED department am I meant to be wearing that mask? I replied to them saying I was unable to wear the mask and hold the bag in case I was sick. I recall they asked was I meant to wear it and I said I wasn’t sure, the staff member at the front told us to wear them but it seemed to me no one else in the ED was wearing them so I wasn’t sure if it was mandatory as I hadn’t been to an exposure site or had symptoms, if so I would be isolating if I was a risk. The clinician then said loudly in what I felt was a degrading tone that I should know better. I should know the pressure the health care system is under.

By this stage I was standing up walking to the consult room. I recall the clinician was behind me yelling at me about not wearing a mask and that it was selfish and that as a clinician, they had to wear a mask all day as did everyone else in the hospital. I asked politely, through tears at this stage,  could I please be assessed by someone else and I believe the clinician said blatantly no, and told me I need to calm down. I said again very calmly but through tears as I was now increasingly distressed that I don’t have to consent to them treating me if they’re going to continue speaking to me like this.

I sat down in the chair and I recall the clinician said that I can go back and wait for someone else. I said no, I’m here now and I believe the clinician watched me struggle to walk here. I recall the clinician said that I didn’t consent to them treating me, so go back and wait for someone else. I said that no, I don’t have to consent to them treating me if they’re going to treat me like this and speak to me the way I believe they did.

The clinician closed the door and asked why am I here? I handed them a letter from my GP/chiro and said that I am in 8-9/10 pain, I have bladder retention, I can’t walk there is something wrong with my back. The clinician read the letter, I recall they said nothing to me, did no observations, asked no questions and did no assessment or observations. Most alarmingly, they did not offer me any pain relief, even paracetamol, after I told them my pain level. The clinician then told me to go wait in the waiting room. I believe I could then see the clinician talking to other staff members about me and my parent believes they could overhear them speaking poorly about me whilst also staring directly at me through the windows.

I was so distressed by this my sibling, who works in healthcare, contacted the CARE team who immediately came to speak with me. I was so upset that I had to ask my parent to speak for me at times as they, and I believe others in the ED, witnessed much of this. I was quickly taken through after this for re assessment and given pain relief and taken through to be assessed.

Whilst I cannot fault the treatment I received after being admitted to the fast track and short stay area (please give my compliments to Diva the RN and also to Jackie the Irish nurse, I couldn’t have gotten through my admission without them and they’re both a credit to the profession), I do feel like my concerns weren’t fully addressed and upon seeking advice privately by a private neuro I am booked in for surgery. I understand the pressures of the health care system and what I feel it must be like being a clinician, but I also know what it’s like to be vulnerable, in pain, scared, concerned and seeking help.

Empathy, respect, kindness are qualities amongst many others that I believe clinicians are required to have and I felt at no point during my triaging was I shown any by the clinician. It was plain and simply the worst experience within a hospital environment that I have ever had and has quite frankly put me off seeking help in the ED.

In my opinion, this is not acceptable for a clinician and under the recommendation of others, I am making this complaint. Quite frankly I know nothing will probably come from it, I’ll likely never get an apology from that clinician or anything else but maybe in the future, they can act with the qualities I believe are expected and obligated of them under the patient charter of rights.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Jeffrey Calver, Director Bunbury Hospital, WA Country Health Service (WACHS) 2 years ago
Jeffrey Calver
Director Bunbury Hospital,
WA Country Health Service (WACHS)
Submitted on 14/01/2022 at 12:33 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 12:33 PM


Dear deltabe36,

Thank you for taking the time to share your experiences at Bunbury Hospital Emergency Department.

I am so sorry to hear about the way that you were treated by the first clinician who called you in for assessment. The behaviour you describe, being spoken to in a degrading and rude manner and not having your pain concerns addressed amongst them, is not what we expect of our Clinical staff in the Emergency Department. I understand that currently it can be very confusing to know what the mask wearing requirements are, but this does not excuse behaviour that leaves you feeling even more confused and feeling degraded. We expect all of our staff to speak to patients with empathy, respect and kindness as you describe and I am sorry that this was not your experience. Your feedback does highlight to me that we have more work to do with some of our ED clinicians to reiterate the important patient rights outlined in the Australian Charter of Healthcare Rights. I commit that we will work with the Heads of Department and Nurse Unit Managers to address this.

I am pleased to read that you were able to use Aishwarya’s CARE Call to support you to escalate your concerns during your presentation and thank you for sharing with us the positive experience you had with our fast track and short stay nurses and I will be sure to pass on your compliments to them.

Your feedback is very timely and valuable to me as it demonstrates to me that we have more work to do in ensuring that all of our staff are kept up to date with the ever-changing requirements of mask wearing in our hospital, and specifically our Emergency Department.

Once again thank you for taking the time to contact me, I hope that your pain is resolving and your planned surgery goes well. I would like an opportunity to further investigate your experience and invite you to contact me directly to discuss your experience further and work together to ensure that improvements are made so a similar experience does not reoccur. I am the Director of Bunbury Hospital and you can contact me on 9722 1484.

Kind Regards

Jeff Calver

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k