This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Deserved better"

About: King Edward Memorial Hospital / Maternal Fetal Assessment Unit King Edward Memorial Hospital / Maternity

(as the patient),

We recently were admitted to King Edwards Memorial Hospital for the birth of our child. During our stay at the hospital supposedly being cared for by the staff, at no point did we feel listened to or respected.

Firstly the stretch and sweeps, of which there were many, were not consented to! They were all performed under the guise of an internal which is a different procedure, it takes a split second during an internal to ask for consent to do a stretch and sweep. Legally your staff are required to get consent before doing so, which they did not! I believe this is abuse, I feel violated and disrespected.

Secondly, during the labour and birth, I made repeated requests for my wishes on my birth plan to be honoured and none of my wants and needs were respected. I recall your staff behaved unprofessionally, arrogantly and treated myself and my spouse like a statistic with little regard to our basic human rights. I felt they created an air of total panic and mayhem during my labour and repeatedly scare mongered and bullied us into making decisions we were not comfortable with. I felt terrified and violated the entire way through instead of supported and cared for. We are aware that birth is not straightforward and sometimes complications can make things difficult however, if dealt with professionally, respectfully and calmly, I believe it didn’t have to be such a horrifyingly traumatic experience for us. We are now left traumatised by the labour, birth and the following our stay on the ward in your hospital.

Based on my experience, the lack of communication between your staff was and is appalling and left us feeling unimportant and uninformed. Your staff made some decisions without any discussion with us. At several points we were not informed of what was happening with myself and our baby. This left us feeling confused, scared and unable to trust your staff.

Thirdly, your seemingly outdated and archaic visitor policy is a total joke in my opinion! As I understand it, most hospitals around the globe now allow partners and spouses to stay overnight with the birth person and newborn child after the birth for support. I feel it is completely unacceptable that a person who has just had a massively traumatic birth be left overnight with substantial post birth injuries, cannular-ised and catheter-ised to recover and care for a newborn baby alone. Especially when it seems you are so short staffed that when the patient presses the assistance button no one comes. Not to mention how I believe the visitor policy discriminates against the partner and spouse and does not allow them to be with their child overnight which is fundamental for bonding. My spouse has missed out on a substantial amount of important quality bonding time with their baby.

I recall covid was used as an excuse for this visitor policy but we heard from other people that this policy has been around pre-covid!

Fourthly, your hospital claims to be LGBTQI+ friendly and even goes as far as to fly the rainbow flag outside and yet we felt we were discriminated against the entire time!

The level of gender and orientation discrimination I felt was shocking and unacceptable, not to mention illegal!

I feel you should remove the flag or properly train your staff and ensure they behave correctly.

We want to be contacted so that at the very least, the written discrimination on our records can be rectified. We feel we deserve a formal apology and change needs to be made now so that this does not continue to happen to other people. Unfortunately we have heard from dozens of other people who have had horrific experiences while birthing at KEMH. We and the local community feel we deserve better from you.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Jodi Graham, Executive Director, Sir Charles Gairdner Osborne Park Health Care Group 2 years ago
Jodi Graham
Executive Director,
Sir Charles Gairdner Osborne Park Health Care Group
Submitted on 9/03/2022 at 12:55 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 12:55 PM


picture of Jodi Graham

Dear aquilany38,

I would like to thank you for taking the time to provide me with your feedback, during which I am sure is a very busy time for you both. I acknowledge that the events that you have described in your feedback would have negatively affected your experience with our hospital, and I apologise for this.

At the King Edward Memorial Hospital (KEMH), we endeavour to provide our patients with exceptional care and a positive birth experience. I am sorry to hear that your stay at KEMH has left you and your partner feeling violated, disrespected and traumatised. We take your feedback very seriously and should you agree, we would like to investigate these very serious concerns.

I am disappointed to hear that you feel that your wishes for your birth plan were not honoured. Care planning is taken very seriously, and changes to a patient’s medical treatment should be explained and discussed with the patient. I am sorry if your changes were not communicated to you in a respectful way. I recognize how these changes to your care can affect your birth experience and I apologise for the distress that this has caused you.

I recognise that becoming a parent is one of the most significant events in a person’s life. I appreciate how important it is for our patients to have their support network available to them throughout their pregnancy journey and the birth of their child. It is the priority of all hospital service providers to focus on providing a COVID-safe health service for our patients, families and staff during this time. Some restrictions are in place in our hospitals to help us do this.

Unfortunately with the current infrastructure and building space at KEMH we are unable to allow partners to stay with patients overnight. The McGowan Government has announced the co-location of KEMH to the QEII site and the matter of rooms which allow for partners to stay overnight is high on the agenda during the planning phase. We are committed to ensuring the design of the hospital will provide patient-centred care.

The events that you have described are very serious and our service would like the opportunity to provide you with an investigation into this situation so that we can provide you with a personalised response and assurance we will strive to improve our service. Should you agree, I encourage you to contact the WNHS Consumer Liaison Service on (08) 6458 1444 or via email WNHSCLS@health.wa.gov.au

I would again like to apologise to you for the experience you had at KEMH and encourage you to contact the Consumer Liaison Service so that a full investigation can be carried out. Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with me. I understand that this would not have been an easy task for you. I wish you and your family all the best for the future and I do hope that we hear from you soon.

Kind regards

Jodi Graham

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k