This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"My hip replacement"

About: Bunbury Hospital / Allied Health Fremantle Hospital and Health Service / Orthopaedic Surgery Department & B7N Fremantle Hospital and Health Service / Outpatients

(as the patient),

When I was first diagnosed with hip dysplasia in both hips I was in my 40s, and the troublesome ceramic joints were being used, after seeing my grandmother having worn out 7 of these, I waited for these ceramic joints to eventually go out of use (this took some years).

The staff at Fremantle hospital were very friendly and helpful, I had a good stay and my surgeon did a good job. In hospital, I observed what I believe to be a lack of updating with assistance equipment and contradiction to some written information. For example, I was told not to bend my hip unnecessarily yet the high chairs used created just the circumstance where hip joints needed to be bent, it made no sense at all. I had the distinct impression that the literature was a leftover from some 20 years ago when ceramic hip joints were being used, this seemed to be confirmed when my surgeon later confirmed that if treated moderately, some of the current hip joints could last up to double the period of 10 years as was put in that brochure. This gave me much more hope of a longer-lasting hip joint.

The questionnaires I filled in were at times, in my opinion, from a different world where the people asking the question did not understand the patient's situation, like asking the question how long before I returned to normal! I had great difficulty answering that question, did they mean before I developed hip pain (which was 25 years ago when I was fully employed) or compared with a semi-retired person! A second example was asking about falls, a young person can trip, but over 50 is regarded as a fall, no matter if you accidentally hit yourself in the face with a 25mm solid steel bar over a metre in length like I did! Now was that a fall or what? However, on leaving I was handed a brochure explaining that the hip joint would only be expected to last 10 years (that's the part that stuck in my mind ) This was somewhat of a let down as I was not elderly and hoped not to require a revision at a later time. I hoped that I could get longer than that having waited 25 years for this operation, waiting for the technology and my age to change.

The wound dressing was done by a nurse at the Australind  Medical Centre, (200 kms from Fremantle) and no issues there, they were nice to deal with and I was making steady progress.

The problems I did have with my hip started when going through the physio and 6-week check periods (not with my surgeon) and almost nobody seemed to have any idea how to deal with a patient that had more than one health issue.

The physio was carried out at the Bunbury Hospital Western Australia, (200 km from Fremantle) where the physio, from their actions, caused me some set back as described. In my opinion, another case of bad work from Bunbury hospital, no doubt, in the guise of medical research data gathering I think. In my opinion, there is research linking a person's ability for balance to their age longevity, and it would seem that this injury to me was an attempt to gather data for such research! I believe the physio was obviously more interested in getting data, than focusing on the real-world situation. Multiple factors affecting my balance. I am not, and have never been an elite sportsman, and it is wrong to treat the whole population as if they were, as I think they do.

The 6-week check was performed at the Fremantle hospital (200kms from home) where a medical person did this progress check on behalf of my surgeon, however, they wanted me to strain my hip more than I believe was required, and it caused a tear in my healing hip muscle. I heard and felt this occur! This later needed a cortisone injection to get past this, if this had not worked a further operation was later offered to rectify this. The cortisone injection in my left hip and the treatment of the right side hip pain were both conducted by Bunbury radiology 200kms from Fremantle Hospital and 20kms from home. The key to this issue is, don't let anyone push you past the point where you can feel is your limit.

The recent instance in Bunbury as I said was one of two instances during my hip recovery where I feel medical persons were not able to understand multiple conditions, and instead focused totally on one aspect while ignoring all else. In no way am I criticizing the surgeon or the nurses, I believe it was the associated medical checks that caused all the damage.

At my 6-month check, my surgeon had returned and conducted this check themselves and put things into place for interventions for both hips as I have explained in my story. Their operation on me had been a success, however, the aftercare by others had set me back in my recovery, and this, in my opinion, was totally unnecessary and used up medical resources that otherwise would not have been required.

I do realise that it is a difficult time due to covid and shortages within hospital staff, but I will remind you that at the time of my hip recovery was going on, my operation was in a specialised hospital that does not have a general emergency department, and Western Australia was, to my understanding, Covid-free with the borders shut, so everything hospital wise was operating quite normally (so I believe they should not use Covid as an excuse).

I eventually made a full recovery and have asked my brilliant surgeon for the other hip to be replaced. I have had my pre-admission appointment and currently waiting for my second hip replacement.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Neil Doverty, Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group, South Metropolitan Health Service nearly 2 years ago
Neil Doverty
Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group,
South Metropolitan Health Service
Submitted on 1/06/2022 at 10:00 AM
Published on Care Opinion at 2:07 PM


picture of Neil Doverty

Dear Bellated,

Thank you for your kind words regarding the staff at Fremantle Hospital and your satisfaction with your overall hip replacement surgery. I am glad to hear that you have made a full recovery.

I have shared your Care Opinion post with the Orthopaedic Team, including the Head of Service (HoS), and we collectively wanted to clarify a couple of your points that specifically relate to Fremantle Hospital:

Regarding not bending your hip unnecessarily – the chairs provided are higher than standard chairs, therefore do decrease flexion on the hip.

Our HoS advised that he is not sure when the literature you were provided with was written, however wanted to reassure you that some statements may be out of date, but the overall gist will be correct. Regardless, we will be completing a review of these materials.

The PROMs questionnaires you are referring to (patient-reported outcome measures) are globally standardised; we do not design the questions. Information collected from PROMs can assist to monitor progress, however will never be the sole monitoring tool. What is more important is the discussions you (or any patient for that matter) have with your treating healthcare professional(s).

Gluteal pain is common after (and before) total hip replacements, and does not necessarily reflect any failure of appropriate rehabilitation. Our HoS wanted to add that surgeons are responsible for both the good and bad aspects of patient journeys. We often hear patients say that the surgeon was great but the outcome was not; either blaming themselves or third parties like physiotherapists, and this demonstrates the limitations of patient feedback. This is one of the reasons why we use PROMs to evaluate our outcomes – being standardised they are more reliable.

Thank you again for your kind words and your feedback – I especially appreciate you taking the time to highlight the literature we provide, which as I said we will be reviewing.

I wish you all the best for your next hip replacement.

Kind regards,

Neil Doverty

Group Executive Director

Fiona Stanley Fremantle Hospitals Group.

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Sarah Amesz, Acute Allied Health Manager, Bunbury Hospital, WACHS South West nearly 2 years ago
Sarah Amesz
Acute Allied Health Manager, Bunbury Hospital,
WACHS South West
Submitted on 1/06/2022 at 5:18 PM
Published on Care Opinion on 2/06/2022 at 8:45 AM


Hi Bellated,

My name is Sarah Amesz and I am the Acute Allied Health Manager from Bunbury Hospital, including the Physiotherapy service. We are grateful for your feedback so that we can review our processes and make improvements.

It sounds like you have had a long journey to get to the point of this hip replacement, with some challenges along the way. I have reviewed your feedback with our Senior Physiotherapist and we are sorry that when you attended Physiotherapy at Bunbury Hospital that you felt that the expectation was that you were able to do more than you could. Every person should be treated based on their individual abilities and potential to improve their balance and movement. We have not been collecting data for any medical research, but we do gather information about what you are able to do and how you are progressing to guide our treatment plan. This assessment should not feel like it is the priority over your treatment though.

I would like to know more about your experience so that we can see if we can make any changes to improve our service, so if you are happy to provide this information, could you contact me or my colleague Sally Barrett (A/Acute Allied Health Manager) on 0408 096 921 or via email (sarah.amesz@health.wa.gov.au or sally.barrett@health.wa.gov.au).

I’m glad you have now made a full recovery and wish you all the best for the replacement of your other hip.

Kind regards,

Sarah

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by Bellated (the patient)

Thanks for your reply,

As a Mechanical Fitter and First Cass Machinist by trade, what you say about the chairs (which I know are higher ) makes no sense to me at all.

The high chairs cause knees and hips to be bent at almost right angles, and I cannot see how this is consistent with not bending a hip joint, surely keeping feet on the floor on a normal height chair and leaning back, or having a reclining chair back, stops one's hips from bending?

At home I found the ideal aid was a reclining chair which enables my hip to be as straight as possible and aids in my initial sitting down as well.

Regarding some of your other points, I need to point out that the gluteal pain you refer to was not general in nature, and only started after being first stressed, I feel unnecessarily, in Bunbury, which healed in 2 weeks,

Then a second time after testing at Fremantle caused a tearing sensation which caused increased pain that did not go away after 4 months more.

In case you didn't get my point, I have suffered hip pain for 25 years, in both hips, since my diagnosis, and 2 years before that diagnosis of hip dysplasia, so I have a really good idea what hip pain is! I do not require further education on this subject.

I am not merely seeking to blame someone for a prolonged recovery, I was asked to make some constructive comments, presumably to improve the relevant services, however unless these service providers are prepared to own these issues, then I have completely wasted my time.

I detest global city-centric standardised forms as I believe they discriminate against country people.

As just one example a useless form question being asked; how many flights of stairs can I manage? This is totally irrelevant for me, as in the country I can go for years without encountering a flight of stairs. Don't get me started about city-centric address forms.

Bellated.

Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k