This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Unacceptable delay in ED"

About: Geraldton Hospital / Emergency Department

(as a parent/guardian),

I brought my teenage child to ED with a head laceration and concerns with concussion.

We had our details taken efficiently and were taken straight to the side-hall for RAT testing. While awaiting the 15 min period, the clerk phoned and complete triage via my mobile. We tested negative and were approved to move into the ED waiting area. I thank the 2 nurses and phone clerk for their friendly efficiency.

Sadly the rest of our experience was highly unsatisfactory.

I believe there were only 2 people waiting ahead of us. I recall it took nearly 3 hours before the first was seen. They left again 15mins later. Another hour passed before the second was seen, who again left after 20-30mins.

A couple of hours after midnight, my teenager was finally taken through. During this 5 hour period… nobody performed any kind of concussion check other than to say my teenager could have Panadol if they wanted.

As you are probably aware, it seems the walls are thin in ED and I believe I was able to hear how quiet the dept was. I was confident that no ambulances or critical patients had presented via the second entrance. Once we were finally seen I asked about the wait and confirmed that the delay was not due to other more urgent patients being triaged ahead of us.

The doctor’s response to my polite expression of frustration at the cold and uncomfortable wait (with the external doors removed, I found the waiting area is very cold on a winter's night). I recall their response was that we should be grateful we’re not on the East coast where we’d be waiting twice as long. I did not find it comforting to think that I should be happy that my concussed and head bleeding teenager would expect to wait 10hrs for treatment.

The second comment was that I don’t need to bring my teenager to ED for this kind of thing and that I could often fix a split scalp by twisting the hair on either side and tie it together with an elastic band. I reassured the doctor that this cut was larger than I believe they thought, and I felt it would need stitches. It seemed the Dr was surprised to see that in fact it was a deep cut that had in fact penetrated the periosteum. My teenager was given 5 staples and we were sent on our way.

I had to ask for instructions re: concussion, particularly in regards to exercise. As I understand it, the doctor didn’t know. The doctor went and took a further 15mins to print out a handout from a website. I had to ask for instructions for would care, such as showering or the need to keep it dry. We left at shortly after.

We are a family that is fully aware and supporting of the triage process and the need for lower priority issues to wait. I believe 5.5hrs to receive a total of 15mins contact with health staff was completely unacceptable.

I believe our experience was a direct result of lack of staffing and reduced clinical space due to hospital renovations.

In my opinion, my teenager, and the Geraldton community, deserve better from our health service.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Ranjit Paul, Director Medical Services, Geraldton Hospital, WA Country Health Service nearly 2 years ago
Ranjit Paul
Director Medical Services, Geraldton Hospital,
WA Country Health Service

Director of Medical Services

Submitted on 7/07/2022 at 5:33 PM
Published on Care Opinion on 8/07/2022 at 8:49 AM


picture of Ranjit Paul

Dear Angry ED Parent

Thank you for sharing your teenager’s experience with us on Care Opinion.

I would like to apologise to yourself and your teenager for the extended wait you experienced after arriving in the Emergency Department. All presentations are graded using the Australasian Triage Scale and our aim is to have most patients medically assessed and treated in two hours. There could be various reasons for not achieving this on the evening your teenager attended, without the exact date I could not confirm if it was related to staffing capabilities, higher than expected presentations, or some other scenario.

If there is a suspected concussion, we have set protocols to be followed, to ensure the patient is cared for and treated appropriately, whilst minimising the risk to them. I shall ensure our ED Managers review these protocols and raise with their teams.

I would like to speak with you or your teenager to provide more in-depth answers to the concerns you’ve raised and to ensure your teenager has received all the treatment and follow up they require. My name is Ranjit Paul and I am the Director Medical Services at Geraldton Hospital. If you are happy to, please call me on 08 9956 2410 or email me at Ranjit.Paul@health.wa.gov.au

So that you are aware, Geraldton Hospital, along with all other public hospitals in the Midwest, has an escalation process in place to support patients and their families and carers if they feel that their own or their loved one’s health is deteriorating. This process is called Aishwarya’s CARE Call and enables the caller to speak with a senior member of staff who will listen to the concerns and seek advice and support for you or your loved one. You may notice in our Emergency Department posters about Aishwarya’s CARE Call. If you are concerned about the care you or your family are receiving in hospital in the future, I encourage you to make a CARE Call on 1800 316 729. If you want to learn more about Aishwarya’s CARE Call, you can visit: WA Country Health Service - Aishwarya’s CARE Call

I do hope your teenager is feeling better and that we hear from you soon.

Yours sincerely

Dr Ranjit Paul

Director Medical Services

Geraldton Hospital

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k