This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Trans and gender diversity (TGD) & social isolation"

About: Bright Hospital / Day Surgery

(as a service user),

I raised my TGD concerns follow-up phone call, and was asked to submit the online form (which I will note provides an opportunity for this to fall through the gaps, as it relies on my capacity to follow through).

I was admitted for a gastroscopy (day procedure) recently.

1) I first want to highlight that staff were accommodating to barriers in terms of social isolation and my own fierce independence, although I was challenged by the idea that when the hospital *requires* someone to have a support person with them overnight, they do not always have the autonomy to refuse, and may be left in the power of the hospital to deny the procedure. I would like to know if there is a process in place to support/accommodate isolated residents who do not have family support.

2) on TGD inclusion: healthcare is a unique situation where the patient is often being talked about in front of themselves, both by name and gendered pronouns. Your systems do not seem to allow an opportunity for people to disclose trans or gender diversity, or preferred name. 'Sex' is the only field in the admission paperwork (something that is relevant in a medical context, and may be more complex than m/f for trans and gender-diverse people).

3) intersection with disability:

I have ptsd from childhood medical trauma that makes it very difficult for me to advocate for myself in the moment. As a result, a general expectation that I advocate for myself on the day or in person is challenging.

2 & 3) While I noted a preferred name on my admissions form, this was overlooked. The admitting nurse was quick to adapt to chosen name and highlight that with the rest of the team when I spoke up on the day, making a note under 'cultural needs' (or similar) and adding it to the front of my file folder. However, when I awkwardly raised that I use they/them pronouns, I felt that was brushed off as being unimportant (and in that moment I was unable to further advocate for myself), so I was constantly referred to as incorrect pronouns throughout.

Overall, my experience was positive. Staff were a friendly team, and seemed well coordinated, shifting patients effectively through an old building that doesn't seem quite designed for the theatre flow-though it gets - a happy compromise at being able to have the procedure done locally.

To improve on trans and gender-diverse inclusion, I believe it would be great to see promotion of training with staff, reinforcing that assumptions based on age and appearance can be wrong. I would also like to see pro-active rather than re-active inclusion - ways to identify that your services are safe and inclusive for lgbtqia+ people, including a contact person that people can access prior to or during admission (along with visible, easily accessible contact information), and ways to highlight specific needs that actually filters through to the treating care team, without depending on lgbtqia people to 'come out' over and over in order to have those needs met.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Tanya Hart, Day Surgery Coordinator, Bright Hospital, Mount Beauty Hospital, Myrtleford Hospital 11 months ago
We are preparing to make a change
Tanya Hart
Day Surgery Coordinator,
Bright Hospital, Mount Beauty Hospital, Myrtleford Hospital
Submitted on 8/05/2023 at 2:19 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 2:51 PM


Thank you ENigmatic BYline. From reading your feedback I would like to acknowledge the challenges you have faced in doing so and would like to pass on our thanks as it allows us to take your suggestions further which will help to make Alpine Health a safer and more inclusive health service.

To work through each point for you:

1. We do offer overnight admission if needed. The doctors can arrange this when booking the procedure if it is needed.

2. We are about to start an organisation-wide audit of all our consumer forms to check that they are sensitive to a range of diversities (including identity). These will be updated to ensure staff ask the right questions, and staff will receive more training to ensure they communicate with consumers in a sensitive and understanding way. Essential medical information will also continue to be collected.

3. We're really sorry that the incorrect use of pronouns left you not being able to self-advocate. There will be more training for staff around the importance of using the correct pronouns.

Thanks again for taking the time to share your experience with us. We want all members of the community to feel safe and confident in seeking health care from us when needed so will undertake work to become a more inclusive organisation. We will update in the coming months on the changes mentioned above.

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by ENigmatic BYline (a service user)

Thank you!

Regarding point 1 and an overnight stay, as someone who has had little experience as a patient, I highlighted at every step that I would not be able to arrange for someone to pick me up, but this was never mentioned. I organised my own accommodation in town. How should an unknowing patient go about finding out what resources are available? We don't know what we don't know.

Response from Tanya Hart, Day Surgery Coordinator, Bright Hospital, Mount Beauty Hospital, Myrtleford Hospital 11 months ago
Tanya Hart
Day Surgery Coordinator,
Bright Hospital, Mount Beauty Hospital, Myrtleford Hospital
Submitted on 9/05/2023 at 4:50 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 5:21 PM


Thank you for the further information that you have provided us with. Given the nature of the concerns I would like to offer an opportunity to meet with Bright Health Services Manager and myself to discuss your concerns further.

Please contact Bright Hospital on 03 5755 0100 and request to speak with Tanya Hart, Day Surgery Coordinator to arrange an appropriate time to meet with us.

Kind regards

Tanya Hart

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k