This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Rehabilitation services"

About: Fiona Stanley Hospital / Emergency Department Fremantle Hospital and Health Service

(as a carer),

I write this as both a warning to others and in an urgent and earnest desire to see something done for future occasions when my spouse is hospitalized, which I feel is almost inevitable, given the apparent lack of ongoing treatment this system provides. The recent glossy print adverts and radio segments tell us all that keeping people on their feet as they age is vital. These also acknowledge that falls in the community requiring hospitalization have increased by 40% in five years.

Here is why!

I took my spouse to Fiona Stanley emergency recently after they fell in our bedroom. This isn't the first time they have fallen. It's not the second, third, fourth or even eighth time in the last six month. Sometimes my spouse has fallen multiple times in a single day. Some of these falls have resulted in extremely serious complications requiring lengthy treatment. On this occasion, as per usual my spouse was assessed and admitted. Numerous scans and tests later (the same each time) I was contacted by a doctor on the phone, to repeat the story I had already given to multiple consultants in Emergency. Does anyone listen? I feel, apparently not. By the way I was contacted twice by phone to discuss my spouse’s needs and for my take on events. I expressed myself clearly and unequivocally: under no circumstances did I feel it was safe to discharge my spouse as they were at extreme risk of a repeat fall. I explained clearly that multiple failed discharges had simply resulted in my spouse injuring themselves again and again, and again. Each time they returned to hospital and a short stint in a medical ward was followed by at home physio. I explained this was not working and longer-term intense physio and reference to a physician specialist was needed for them to regain strength and confidence. I knew Fiona Stanley had a new rehab facility (a doctor told me) and asked my spouse to be transferred there at the very least or given they had private insurance, that my spouse get transferred to a private health service. I was assured that Fiona Stanley rehab was excellent but getting my spouse in ...would be difficult. I was told options would be examined and I would be contacted once a plan was in place. I was not contacted.

The next I heard was from my frantic spouse the next morning saying there were four people in their room packing my spouse’s things and saying they were being transferred to Fremantle Hospital. Zero consultation with anybody.

My spouse lasted two days in that place. Staff that seemingly didn't know the common names of prescription drugs but assumed similar ones did the same things. Staff that say no when asked for a hot drink to ease pain and sleeplessness. I recall paint peeling off walls, windows so filthy I could hardly see through them. Food that, in my opinion, is the same as served in prisons apparently. And of course, my spouse was discharged without warning, again with no consultation with me or addressing concerns about ongoing falls or any ongoing support.

All in all, the whole system has let my spouse down badly in my opinion and the stay on your feet message is just a joke. And here is why.

Reading the above you have probably assumed my spouse was elderly, infirm and suffering from age related issues. Wrong, my spouse is in their early sixties. You see, I believe the 'system' is not geared to help longer rehab for someone like my spouse with arthritic conditions...they don’t fit the profile. So, my spouse can't access the long-term rehab at Fiona Stanley because they aren’t over sixty-five or of aboriginal descent it seems. Just no way can this system help you if you don't fit into a particular box. Just shuffle my spouse off to Freo then discharge, again.

Why can't my spouse get proper treatment because they are not yet sixty-five? Why is my spouse’s ethnicity a factor in their care options?

Moreover, why does it seem that the medical people we saw think repeating the same thing over and over expecting change is anything other than insanity? I get the system is stressed and nurses etc are overworked. I also understand complex treatments sometimes get bundled to the back of the queue but that is not my spouse's fault.

So fix it.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Neil Doverty, Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group, South Metropolitan Health Service 7 months ago
Neil Doverty
Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group,
South Metropolitan Health Service
Submitted on 3/10/2023 at 5:02 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 5:30 PM


picture of Neil Doverty

Dear Wrongprofile

I am sorry that you and your spouse feel that their needs are not being met each time they present to hospital.

I understand that patients and their carers find it frustrating when they have to repeat themselves each time, they come to hospital, but this is required for patient safety and to check if there have been any changes from the previous assessment. It is also often the case that scans will be undertaken following each fall to check for hidden injuries, the doctors are not able to depend on historical scans if there is a new fall.

I can hear the frustration in your feedback and would like to further investigate the issues you have raised, particularly in relation to access to rehabilitation services. I encourage you to contact the Fiona Stanley Fremantle Hospital Group Patient and Family Liaison Service on 6152 4013 (Monday to Friday 8.30 am to 4.30 pm), or anytime via email at FSHFeedback@health.wa.gov.au.

We look forward to hearing from you soon.

Kind regards,

Neil Doverty

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by Wrongprofile (a carer)

Hey Neil, I haven't had time to respond to you because my spouse was again taken to Fiona Stanley hospital by ambulance (urgent) 14 days after their supposed discharge in September. So again, various doctors listened to me, said it was indeed a failed discharge under their KPI's, said they would take action and yes, they would not discharge my spouse again without discussing with me and courses of appropriate action. And guess what? They again discharged them without consultation or a care plan.

In my opinion, this is a Monty Python script surely? Have you people any idea what you are doing? Doctors with dark rings under their eyes, nurses that I feel look like rabbits caught in a spotlight...that's the health system in WA in my experience. Your system is entirely broken, unresponsive and incapable of providing proper care....in my opinion of course.

PS, I did complain to the Human Rights Commission who said my spouse wasn't an ethnic minority or sexually or racially discriminated against...in their opinion. So everyday Australians are apparently excluded from complaining. So, there you go, we are now seemingly no longer relevant.

PPS, Neil the Care Number you provide on your website...you know the one to discuss patient concerns.... well, it rings out Neil. Yup, it doesn't answer.

Response from Neil Doverty, Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group, South Metropolitan Health Service 6 months ago
Neil Doverty
Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group,
South Metropolitan Health Service
Submitted on 10/10/2023 at 10:41 AM
Published on Care Opinion at 10:54 AM


picture of Neil Doverty

Dear Wrongprofile,

Thank you for keeping me updated on this evolving situation. I am deeply disappointed to learn that following a further required admission to FSH you have experienced a repeated lack of communication and involvement in the discharge planning process for your spouse. We know at FSH how integral discharge planning with the patient and their families is when transitioning them back to home and I am just extremely sorry that this was once again not your experience.

It reads, and I acknowledge from your feedback, that the organisation of your spouse’s discharge home was suboptimal, and I can completely appreciate the frustration you would both be feeling as a result of this.

I understand that you did attempt to contact our Patient and Family Liaison Service on (08) 6152 4013 and I can only apologise you were unsuccessful in speaking with someone. I have followed up personally myself with the Manager of the Department to ensure and confirm there is a voicemail service activated on this contact number to enable consumers to leave a message for their call to be returned if they are unable to answer the phone. The sentiment remains that I would really value the opportunity to understand your experience in further detail so we can truly learn what can be done differently and provide me the opportunity to feedback to the staff involved in your spouse’s care.

I wish your spouse all of the best in their recovery, and I hope to hear from you soon.

Kind regards

Neil Doverty

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k