This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Confusing for visitors, no communication and parking nightmare"

About: Fiona Stanley Hospital

(as a relative),

I have had specialist appointments at the specialist centre in the past and I've found parking has been so impossible I have resorted to parking at a friends place and walking over 1km with my small child to attend his appointment after driving 2 hours to Perth.

Recently I brought my elderly parent to visit their sibling who is currently a patient at Fiona Stanley hospital. I knew parking near the specialist centre was next to impossible so we went round the back to the multi storey car park. I only knew it was there from a previous visit as mentioned above, because there are no signs directing people to visitors parking. There is no signage to indicate the entrance to the parking area, we had to circle back to enter. I’m not sure if it’s all been removed due to the construction works? Once inside we eventually found a parking spot. I noticed there was then no signage to indicate how to actually get into the hospital from the car park. We entered the rehab centre where we had to seek out a staff member and were directed downstairs and made our way into the main hospital. Once inside we found out way to our family members room. It doesn’t help that our family member was moved rooms over 4 times in a 10 day stay. My parent (next of kin) was not notified of any room changes and actually walked in one day to find a stranger instead of their sibling in the room they expected their sibling to be in.

My parent found this very distressing.

My parent also found it distressing that they, as next of kin, was not notified when their sibling's surgery had been cancelled (multiple times) , when their sibling eventually did go in for surgery and when they came back to the ward. Zero communication from Fiona Stanley about anything to do with their next of kin. My parent felt belittled by staff every time they tried to call to find out about their sibling.

My parent also struggled to walk the distance from the high rise parking area into the hospital and back.

I consider myself to be fairly well travelled and good at finding my way around (I do not live in Perth), but found the whole experience very confusing. I feel sorry for elderly and disabled people who just want to visit their loved ones in hospital.

I feel that better signage for visitors and communication with next of kin would go a long way.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Neil Doverty, Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group, South Metropolitan Health Service 7 months ago
Neil Doverty
Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group,
South Metropolitan Health Service
Submitted on 4/10/2023 at 2:48 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 4:41 PM


picture of Neil Doverty

Dear Countrymouse123,

Thank you for sharing your experience regarding FSH with me. Feedback such as yours is a very helpful perspective when we think about how we can improve our patient’s experience at FSH.

FSH has over 3500 car park bays, so I’m surprised you found it impossible to park. Car Park 5 alone has almost 750 bays. The Murdoch precinct FSH is located within is one of the most highly serviced public transportation precincts in Perth. As such we really do need our staff and patients (particularly outpatients) to take advantage of this whenever possible.

Thank you also for your feedback regarding the signage. The signage is regularly reviewed, including by our Consumer Advisory Committee, but I will ask that they complete another site-wide review and audit. FSH is not able to comment on the site construction works next door.

Frequent room changes are something that we do our best to avoid, but unfortunately at times we do need to move patients, ideally to their “home specialty” ward if a bed was not available there upon admission. I am sorry to read that your parent was distressed when they could not locate their sibling, it’s important for everyone to knock before entering a patient bedroom if the door is closed. Alternatively, approach one of our Ward Clerks or a member of the Ward nursing or therapy team will be happy to guide to the right bedroom.

Generally next of kins are not routinely notified of their loved one’s progress unless specifically requested – particularly if the patient is deemed mentally competent. We are obliged to deeply respect patient confidentiality at all times. I am unable to identify your parent and family member’s particular admission or circumstances, but I do encourage all patients and their carers to speak with the Nurse Unit Manager to seek clarification regarding any aspect of treatment plans or care.

Regarding the long distance between car parks and the main hospital – we do have a fabulous team of volunteers. You may have noticed them situated at the main (west) entrance of the hospital. They are a brilliant resource for wayfinding, but also have golf-buggies and can come and collect patients / visitors from carparks if required. They can be contacted via the switch on 6152 2222. This may be handy for future reference for you.

Warm regards,

Neil Doverty.

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by Countrymouse123 (a relative)

Hi Neil;

I've had the misfortune of having another family member admitted to FSH recently and upon enquiring at the main reception about the golf buggy service from the car park for my other parent who has difficulty walking I was informed that this service has been discontinued. The staff member I interacted with was under the impression this service had been discontinued some time in 2020 due to Covid.

I stayed with my parent for 7 hours while they were admitted through ED (they arrived by helicopter from a rural location) to a ward and paid $21 for parking. I will have to return each day during their stay. Quite frankly I feel this is disgusting that a hospital charges so much for people in their darkest times while rushing to the hospital unsure if their family member will live or die. I didn’t leave the hospital last night until close to midnight, please don’t be condescending and suggest I take public transport in the middle of the night by myself.

I am disappointed you seemingly do not keep up to date with the services your hospital provides.

Response from Neil Doverty, Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group, South Metropolitan Health Service 6 months ago
Neil Doverty
Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group,
South Metropolitan Health Service
Submitted on 19/10/2023 at 3:45 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 5:05 PM


picture of Neil Doverty

Dear Countrymouse123,

I am sorry to hear that you have another family member unwell! Thank you for alerting me to the golf buggy situation. I have made enquiries with the Volunteer Manager who informed me that the buggy was taken out of service by the Road Safety Commission as remedial works to some pavement areas were required. I was not aware of this so am grateful that your post triggered me being informed of this – thank you. I have been advised that once the remedial works are actioned (plus an exemption to enable the buggy to be used on a previously agreed route is obtained), the buggy will return to service.

In the interim, we do have a ring-road which enables the pickup and drop-off of patients and visitors to the main entrance, if required. The following link is for the Fiona Stanley Hospital website page and includes site maps and parking information that you may find helpful; Fiona Stanley Fremantle Hospitals Group - Coming to Fiona Stanley Hospital (health.wa.gov.au).

Regarding the $21 per day parking, that fee is set by the Metropolitan Access and Parking Strategy (MAPS), which provides a framework under which each public health campus in the metropolitan area can deliver consistent policies and practices. MAPS was endorsed by the Ministers for Health and Planning and was formally released by the Director General in 2010.

I hope that your loved one is recovering well – I have every confidence in the care our wonderful team of medical, nursing, allied health and ancillary staff provide.

Kind regards,

Neil Doverty.

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k