Text size

Theme

Language

"OT services"

About: Carnarvon Hospital

(as a service user),

I am an elderly Aboriginal person living in Carnarvon and was worried about falling, so my Dr referred me to the OT department at Carnarvon Hospital for assistance with a falls alarm late 2023 - no response.

With a second referral I went to Outpatients a few months ago and was told by the receptionist that I would have to go out of the building and phone the OT, which I did a little while later and was told by the OT receptionist that I couldn't see the therapist because they were in a meeting and that the 2nd receptionist, couldn't make an appointment for me.

I had an appointment in Geraldton with Hearing Australia last month so I again telephoned the OT department in Carnarvon to see if an appointment had been made for me. The receptionist responded that they haven't had time to check if any referrals have come through and I'd have to go to another area to find out!

So I went to Geraldton and did in fact fall on the cement floor in the laundry a few days later. I suffer from osteo-arthritis and sometimes breathing  issues, so it took me some time to pull myself up by sliding along to the laundry trough. I had been practising getting up from falls, which is difficult when you are in pain and have weak ankles, and because I've had a cartilage removed from one knee, I find it too painful to kneel.

Just under 2 weeks later, 2 OT students came to my home to do an assessment and arranged for me to get a shower chair, which they delivered the next day. 

One of the students left me a message to call them and that they were leaving Carnarvon the next day. I had appointments all day and didn't get their message until the evening.

I eventually spoke to the Occ. Therapist some days later who informed me that the student hadn't left much information about my assessment.  From what they could see:

1. I did not qualify for an alarm because I have been practising at home to get up by myself and being elderly didn't alter that fact. 

2. That I wasn't suffering from dizzy spells any more! (How would they know?)

3. When I told them about having physio at a private clinic they seemed disinterested.  (The only reason I went to a private clinic is because the services supplied at the hospital was closed down due to Covid 19).

4. The OT also said that my fall was 1 year ago, this was an outright lie. I did not fall a year ago, as stated above I fell in Geraldton last month.

When I explained that I suffer from weak ankles, the OT wanted to come back with a physiotherapist and do another assessment.

I felt the OT was being very condescending in their attitude and did not appear to be listening to anything I had to say and it is for that reason I did not agree to this second assessment. 

I mean how many assessments do health professionals need to do before they get it right and where was the supervisor of the young trainees who visited me?

I had also been referred to Silver Chain in 2022 and again last month to get help with some cleaning - still no response from that department as well.

Finally I have found that some of the service providers at the Carnarvon Hospital seem to be in dire need of cross-cultural communication training or maybe they should just simply learn how to communicate properly with people.

I worked in the health industry until my retirement and am appalled at the way I have been treated. I am not someone who is ignorant of health issues and services and neither, I believe, are most mature Aboriginal Australians. Therefore I am not surprised when, based on my experience, they react violently to some front line workers attitudes. 

Where do vulnerable community members go to qualify for health care services that I believe wider community members accept as a foregone conclusion in Carnarvon?

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Megan Grazziadelli, Coordinator Allied Health, Allied Health, WA Country Health Service - Midwest 13 months ago
Megan Grazziadelli
Coordinator Allied Health, Allied Health,
WA Country Health Service - Midwest

Coordinator Allied Health.

Submitted on 17/05/2024 at 4:32 PM
Published on Care Opinion Australia on 20/05/2024 at 9:21 AM


picture of Megan Grazziadelli

Dear hekads58,

Thank you for reaching out on Care Opinion and sharing your story for us to read and reflect on.

I am sorry that you have had a recent difficult time with your health and an unsatisfactory experience in regard to your involvement with our Gascoyne-based Allied Health Services.

Our aim is to provide comprehensive allied health support for all members of our community. I would like to offer my apologies that we have failed to meet your expectations and would like to assure you that we shall seek to make improvements based on your valuable comments.

I understand the aged care system can be difficult to navigate at times and I would like to speak with you so I can ensure we do everything possible to support you and ensure your safety at home. We strongly believe in a “no wrong door” policy and are happy to liaise with your General Practitioner to ensure all of your referrals have gone to the relevant organisations – including us - for actioning.

My name is Megan Grazziadelli, I am the Coordinator of Allied Health and can be reached on 9956 8143 or if you prefer to email megan.grazziadelli@health.wa.gov.au.

Kind regards

Megan Grazziadelli

Coordinator Allied Health

WA Country Health Service – Midwest

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Kumar Deep, Operations Manager- Gascoyne, WA Country Health Service 13 months ago
Kumar Deep
Operations Manager- Gascoyne,
WA Country Health Service
Submitted on 17/05/2024 at 5:14 PM
Published on Care Opinion Australia on 20/05/2024 at 9:21 AM


picture of Kumar Deep

Dear hekads58

I appreciate you sharing your experience with us.

I would also like to offer my apologies if any Carnarvon Hospital staff member did not assist you fully or they were insensitive to your cultural situation when they communicated with you.

I will raise your concerns with the administration team and reconfirm our expectation that they would seek a suitable Allied Health staff member to speak with a consumer, or if not available offer a callback when staff become available.

I will liaise with our Regional Aboriginal Health Consultant to investigate staff training options beyond the mandatory Aboriginal Cultural Learning course that all staff must complete. I would like to extend an invitation for you be involved in these discussions as consumer participation ensures our training provides community benefit.

My name is Kumar Deep, I am the Operations Manager Gascoyne. My phone number is 9941 0300 or I can be emailed at kumar.deep@health.wa.gov.au

Regards

Kumar Deep

Operations Manager Gascoyne

WA Country Health Service - Midwest

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k