This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Incorrect diagnosis"

About: Collie Hospital / Emergency Department

(as the patient),

I was incredibly ill and submitted myself to the Emergency Department (ED) in Collie. Symptoms indicative of influenza/pneumonia and an infection, possibly post op.

Upon entry, I followed the GP clinic sign at the hospital, it was unattended and has a sign saying if it is unattended, to proceed to the front reception. I believe this was when the Coronavirus was just beginning to affect normal operations and I proceeded to the front desk where I felt I was berated by the staff member for being there... being asked, didn’t I see the signs? I came in another door and saw no signs except for GP clinic and was then told to go outside. I felt the staff member was incredibly rude!

I was then contacted in the car park by telephone, provided with a mask and lead into the ED. My vitals were checked and normal but after being seen by 3 different nurses, including the head nurse that day, I was left feeling patronised by comments that it could be anything, possibly my soap. I explained that I was 3 weeks post op and severely ill. I asked to see a GP and was refused and told to go and sit down at the nurses station down town.

I was too ill so I returned home and went back to bed. My spouse convinced me to go to another ED thankfully. I was admitted to this hospital for five days and then released with a diagnosis of Pneumonia, Erythema Nodosum and possibly a post op infection, which led to me being wheelchair bound for a period of time.

After explaining what had happened to staff at both the Collie Hospital and the other hospital, I was asked to publish my comments in the hope of assisting a system clearly in need of fine tuning one way or another. I felt completely let down by our local hospital that day, which led me to becoming anxious about attending hospital to the point where my life was ultimately put in jeopardy.

In my opinion, the head nurse at Collie hospital needs further education in dealing with seriously unwell patients and not making uninformed diagnoses whilst being belittling at the same time.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Lucy Murphy, A/Operations Manager, Inland Hospitals, WA Country Health Services - South West 4 years ago
Lucy Murphy
A/Operations Manager, Inland Hospitals,
WA Country Health Services - South West
Submitted on 8/04/2020 at 11:43 AM
Published on Care Opinion at 11:44 AM


Dear Patient Z,

Thank you very much for taking the time to share your experience in the Emergency Department (ED) at Collie Hospital.

I was disappointed and concerned to hear about what happened in the hospital ED, at what must have been a very difficult and frightening time for you and your family.

I would like to explore what happened and investigate some of the other issues that you have raised. If you are happy to, I would appreciate it if you could contact me so that I can learn more about your experience. My name is Lucy Murphy and I am the A/District Manager. My phone number is 0438 104 845 or you can contact me via Lucy.Murphy@health.wa.gov.au

I am pleased that you were encouraged to share your story on Care Opinion and thank you, again, for doing this. Our patients and their families and carers provide us with invaluable insights into how we can improve what we do. I will share and use your feedback to remind our healthcare staff to trust that people are experts in their own health and wellbeing and the importance of being kind and compassionate when we are caring for people at their most vulnerable moments.

While I hope that you don’t need to attend the ED again, I want you to feel confident that you will be respected and well cared if you do.

I do hope that you are recovering well and hope to hear from you soon.

Yours sincerely

Lucy Murphy

A/District Manager, Wellington (Collie, Harvey & Donnybrook Hospitals)

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k