This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Mistreatment at emergency department"

About: Kalgoorlie Health Campus / Emergency Department

(as a parent/guardian),

Recently, I went to the hospital to take my 3 niblings who are in my care, to get a check up as it seemed to me they were really sick and needed to see a doctor. I saw a clinician beforehand and was put into the COVID room.

I believe I was there 4 or 5 hours with the kids who became restless and I was becoming stressed as well. So I went to the front desk and asked nicely how long they reckon it will take or even an estimate. I recall the clinician spoke in a rude manner and made me feel shame and embarrassed. I remember I replied to them and said that I never asked how many room and beds they had I asked how long it will be till the kids see a doctor. I was so upset by the way the clinician spoke to me and the way I felt I got treated and believe that's not right to treat anyone in that way.

At the entrance where you go in to see a dr, I recall a different clinician was just standing there staring at me which I found very intimidating and so I asked them if they just going to stand there and stare at me. The clinician opened the door and all I said was how I felt it was rude as the clinician went back in the emergency part. I believe, the clinician then called code black as I was still standing there with my niblings. Then the clinician came out and told me to leave. I recall I said something along the lines of no I am not going anywhere, I’ve been here all morning waiting patiently to see the doctor. After the clinician told me to leave I had words with them asking them to write a letter on why I had to leave. In the meantime, it seemed to me the other patients addressed the situation on my behalf too as I believe they had heard and seen how the clinician was treating me and I recall they said if you don't go then security will ask me to leave.

The kids were upset, tired, sick and I felt they didn't even take into consideration how the kids were feeling and how the situation made me feel by being disrespected. I left, feeling shamed, treated unfairly and rang the department about what happened as these children just came into my care and all I was trying to do was access some help for their sickness and I get treated like this.

I spoke to the manager, Kylie, who I felt was very caring and helpful to explain my situation and they organised for a doctor to see my niblings in the kids ward which I found to be a much more calmer and nice environment. We spent the whole day at the hospital and it was the most stressful day on us all after the way we felt we were treated by the staff in ED.

I believe nobody should be treated like that regardless of what race or colour you are and I have not experienced such behaviour under any circumstances. I went for medical help and you are supposed to feel safe and get the best medical care possible at all times and I believe we have a right to be treated with respect when we are asking for information or an update on how long – which I feel is not much to ask for.

In my opinion, it's important your staff need to have or show a bit of empathy and compassion in stressful situations where I believe that they don't know the underlying issues, but also don't assume you know, and treat all fairly and as human beings. I am also a worker for a facility managed by WACHS too so it was very distressing and shameful to be treated like this. I want it addressed so others don't have to go through what I experienced.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Peter Tredinnick, Executive Director, Regional Office, WACHS Goldfields 2 years ago
Peter Tredinnick
Executive Director, Regional Office,
WACHS Goldfields

Executive Director WACHS Goldfields

Submitted on 5/11/2021 at 2:20 PM
Published on Care Opinion on 9/11/2021 at 11:02 AM


picture of Peter Tredinnick

Dear talonhw65,

Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback about the distressing experience you had recently in the Emergency Department at Kalgoorlie Hospital.

I sincerely apologise that you were left feeling intimidated and felt a sense of shame during a visit to the Emergency Department. I would like to assure you that your description of what happened is not the behaviour we expect from any of our staff and is certainly not reflective of the values that we share across our health service.

While Emergency Departments can at times be stressful and highly charged environments, this in no way excuses any of our staff from being rude and disrespectful to our patients and their families and carers. Thank you for acknowledging the caring manager who spoke with you. I am very pleased that this particular staff member was helpful in facilitating a review of your niblings in an area which was a more calming environment.

I am also unsure why the clinician felt the need to call a code black and can understand why this would have been very upsetting for you. I am sincerely sorry that this happened. I would like to have the opportunity to undertake a review of this and the other issues you have identified in your story, so we can make sure that this kind of situation does not happen to another person and their family.

If you would like to discuss any of the issues you have raised further or if we can offer you any other kind of support, please do not hesitate to contact Scott Jones, who is the Operations Manager of Kalgoorlie Hospital, on 9080 5801. Scott will be more than happy to talk with you and would welcome your call.

Thank you, again, for you feedback as it will help us in continually improving the experience of our patients and their families and carers and will improve our clinicians’ practice overall.

I hope your niblings are feeling better.

Kind regards

Peter Tredinnick
Regional Director
WACHS Goldfields

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k