This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"ED response to my teenager with concussion"

About: Swan Hill District Hospital / Emergency Department

(as a parent/guardian),

My teenager sustained a concussion playing football recently after a hard tackle from height and landed on their head with a hard impact. Couldn't walk, severe head and neck pain with double and blurred vision. Trainers asked me to take my teenager to ED fairly quickly due to the type of impact.

Attended ED mid-afternoon, where my teenager said they had a slightly runny nose, so we were put in what I felt was the dirty room. After a while, we were verbally triaged from the other side of the plastic - lots of others around and no privacy - and then waited to be seen.

We were taken by the doctor to the temporary building, and my teenager went through their symptoms. They hadn't vomited, so that seemed to be a deal-breaker to assessing further. Pupils were checked with mobile phone torch, no other assessment. I asked for my teenager's blood pressure to be checked and was told if there was a problem, they wouldn't be sitting on the chair. Still had blurry and double vision and unstable on feet. BP was taken - careful not to contact skin - and reading was normal. Told we could go home. The doctor asked if we knew where to find information on concussion and my teenager said 'internet?' then they doctor printed off some information from RCH for us to read.

My teenager complaining that it was the worst headache they had ever had and their neck was really sore. The doctor got my teenager to turn their head from side to side, and it was restricted on one side. We asked about Xray and CT, and were told the radiation levels would be too high for a teenager. Would consider if they deteriorated, and we could come back. Doctor said we could stay for a bit longer 'if we wanted to'.

We stayed as we weren't comfortable leaving and my teenager was given panadol and nurofen.

We were left alone in the portable building, no nurses around, for another 30 minutes. My teenager was in a lot of pain, and was very uncomfortable. When the doctor came back, they said we could go home. We were still concerned about my teenager's symptoms, but they doctor told us to go home and let them sleep.

We left ED, and my teenager spent 3 days in bed, predominantly sleeping. Headache and neck pain persists and they feel like the back of their head is cramping. They are still unsteady on their feet at times and walking slowly.

We got in to see GP and have a neck x-ray booked.

My complaint is that my teenager wasn't triaged properly.

They didn't have basic observations taken.

No one physically touched my teenager and there was no physical or neurological assessment. They landed on their head, couldn't walk properly and had double and blurred vision, and head and neck pain.

They attended last year with a concussion, where we were told my teenager needed to stay for 4 hours for neuro observations.

I don't feel that my teenager was listened to, and I would have expected them to have an x-ray at a minimum, which would have been very reassuring, given they landed on their head, and radiology was already in the hospital.

They would also have appreciated being triaged privately, rather than in front of others.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Chloe Keogh, Executive Director of Clinical Care, Executive Offices, Swan Hill District Health nearly 2 years ago
Chloe Keogh
Executive Director of Clinical Care, Executive Offices,
Swan Hill District Health

Overall responsibility for the running of the health service, reports to the Board of Management. Acting for 3.5 months to replace Long Service Leave.

Submitted on 3/06/2022 at 3:09 PM
Published on Care Opinion at 3:09 PM


picture of Chloe Keogh

Dear scoreboardcx57,

Thank you for taking the time to write to us about your teenager’s care in our ED after a football injury. There are a number of elements in your situation that are alarming and I would really appreciate you getting in touch with us so that we can look at your teenager’s file and check through the care provided.

You identify that you don’t feel that your teenager was triaged correctly, and that there was no privacy in the communication during this time in the waiting room, that there were no basic observations, that your teenager was not listened to, and that there wasn’t 4 hours of neurological observations attended like in previous head injury presentations you have had with your teenager, and that your teenager still, some days later, has an unsteady and slow gait.

Unfortunately due to the restrictions in the department both from a limited design in an aging facility and also the need to isolate for Covid, the symptomatic isolation process, is not ideal and does result in some patient to clinician interaction in a shared space. Staff are very mindful of this when asking patient details to ensure privacy is maintained as much as possible or patient relocation options considered. The temporary building you describe has been implemented to help provide a relocation option when indicated for symptomatic patients. It appears the decision by the doctor at the time had determined the injury was not severe enough to warrant the effects of unnecessary radiation and documentation had been provided on concussion should the condition worsen. I apologise if this decision had not been clearly explained to you on the day, and that the care your teenager received was not what you were expecting to occur on this day following the particular injury they sustained.

There are a number of things here that seem unusual, and not the usual care processes for this type of injury, and our senior ED Doctor is more than happy to investigate your teenager’s case and the care provided to ensure a full review of your case, and for the ED staff to learn from your experience. For this to occur we will need some details from you.

Please contact me on ckeogh@shdh.org.au, or 0417 706 062 so that I can get more information from you to review this case.

Again, I would like to thank you for taking the time to write about your teenager’s experience. This must have been a most worrying time for you.

I look forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.

Kind regards,

Chloe

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k